[ Content | View menu ]

Archive

The end of the Frederick A. Cook Society?

June 14, 2011

2010 was not kind to the Frederick A. Cook Society.
First, Dr. Ralph Myerson, a Philadelphia area M.D. and long-time treasurer of the society passed away on January 31. Dr. Meyerson was 91. I had a number of dealings with Dr. Myerson over the last fifteen years and always found him to be courteous and accommodating. He was interested in Cook as a fellow medical doctor, and contributed many pieces to the Cook Society’s publications on medical aspects of polar exploration. He never openly advocated for Cook’s attainment of the pole in any of these. He represented the society at several conferences, including the Belgica Centennial Conference held in Brussels in April of 1998. His paper, “Frederick A. Cook, M.D. , the art and science of medicine aboard the Belgica,” was published in the proceedings of that conference.
Next, the long-time sitting president of the society, Warren B. Cook, died on March 25, a few days short of his 80th birthday. Mr. Cook, who was a New Jersey insurance man, met his great uncle, Frederick Cook, as a small boy, and was very devoted to him as an adult. Warren Cook was the grandson of Frederick Cook’s brother, William, who partnered with him in their Cook Brothers Milk and Cream Company business in Brooklyn, NY, before Frederick Cook took a medical degree in 1890. Mr. Cook, like Dr. Myerson, was also very courteous and accommodating and granted me unlimited access to Dr. Cook’s papers and the rights to quote from them in connection to the publication of Cook and Peary in 1997. It was a difficult task to inform him shortly before my book was published that my research had come to the definite conclusion that both Cook’s claim to have ascended Mt. McKinley and to have attained the North Pole were fabrications. After the book was published, I had little contact with Mr. Cook, but before my negative conclusions appeared he wrote to me, “The Cook Society is very appreciative of your meticulous and unparalleled research of Dr. Cook’s life and achievements. Other than not having met him, you know more about him than his Grand Nephew.”
Finally, the society’s executive director and editor of its publications, Russell Gibbons, passed away on September 24 at 78. A native of Hamburg, New York, he became involved in the Cook saga when he chose Cook for the subject of his undergraduate thesis, taking up the standard Cook line that he was discredited by a monied conspiracy that deprived Cook of his rightful claim to the Pole. Apparently, Mr. Gibbons, long-time director of communication for the United Steel Workers in Pittsburgh, had an “us against them” mindset and a fondness for conspiracies, so Cook’s story had a strong appeal. Gibbons always professed an open mind about the truth of Cook’s claims in public, but, in reality, he was very heavy-handed in dealing with anyone who opposed Cook. At one of the conferences the Cook Society sponsored, Gibbons was observed removing literature and articles that provided evidence that Cook had not been to the summit of McKinley or reached the North Pole, which had been placed on a table provided for handouts for conference attendees, even though no restrictions had been placed on what could be given out. According to public records, Gibbons was paid a considerable sum yearly for his editorial services on behalf of the society, but its publications suffered as a result. Although he edited a number of publications for USW and other organizations throughout his career, his work for the society was very shoddy, both factually and physically. When the proceedings of the 1993 conference on Cook was released by Ohio State University some years later, it must have been an embarrassment to anyone involved in the conference, due to its gross editorial mistakes and misrepresentations.
The deaths of these three officers of the society follows closely on the dissipation of the last of the substantial funds provided the society to promote Dr. Cook’s claims by his last lineal ancestor, his grand-daughter Janet Vetter. Much of these funds was spent on an ill-advised republication of Cook’s four published books. These titles, all in the public domain, were soon-after offered by a number of print-on-demand publishing companies, leaving the society holding a large stock of unsalable physical books. More money went to several conferences designed to lend academic stature to Cook’s achievements. The society’s annual payments to Ohio State University to conserve a collection of papers the Cook Society had in its possession further senselessly depleted society funds; they could have been donated to the Library of Congress and thereby be reunited with his other papers and conserved at no cost. More went to fund dubious “expeditions,” such as two that tried to retrace the route Cook claimed to have used to summit Mt. McKinley in 1906. The leaders of both said they had proved Cook had made the climb, but each came to diametrically opposite conclusions on the route he took. And a substantial amount was used to compensate Gibbons for “editorial” work and other society officers for “historical research,” even though such payments are not allowed under the terms of NY State’s non-profit educational corporation statutes under which the society is organized. Finally, a rather inartistic monument placed in Forest Lawn Cemetery in Buffalo, near the columbarium where Cook’s ashes are stored, all but finished off the trust funds.
At an International Polar Year conference in Philadelphia in 2008, there were rumors of the society’s insolvency. Funds had run so low by the centennial of Cook and Peary’s claims in September 2009, that Warren Cook felt compelled to ask for donations to keep the society going. This plea appeared in the last newsletter the society published, the publication of its annual journal having already ended for lack of funds. For twenty years, Janet Vetter’s trust fund had made the society a player in the ongoing Polar Controversy. But with the three Cook stalwarts at the heart of the organization gone, and the once-substantial trust funds depleted, it seems unlikely that the Cook Society will be able to have much of a future role except as the low-profile booster club it was before Vetter’s death.

News

The Centennial of Dr. Cook’s “confession.”

January 14, 2011

Cook back from Exile 1910
In 1910 Hampton’s Magazine paid Peary $40,000 for the rights to his serialized narrative of his conquest of the pole. This series turned out to be a financial disaster, failing to recoup even this, much less the additional $50,000 Benjamin Hampton spent on advertising it. Perhaps to try to recover his loses, he secretly negotiated a similar series from Frederick Cook, then living secretly in London. Hampton’s idea was to have Cook write an account of why he faked his polar attempt, but Hampton’s agents found Cook unwilling to make any such admission. Cook duly wrote a series of articles for Hampton in which he attempted to explain his recent disappearance and to allege a conspiracy of big money and power had deprived him of his accomplishment. Once written, Hampton’s editors struck out most of the anti-Peary statements and played up Cook’s frank admission that it was impossible to say if he had actually reached the exact mathematical point known as the North Pole.confession

Their changes gave an appearance of mental delusion or doubt that he came anywhere near it. Hampton then promoted the story as “Dr. Cook’s Confession.” The first installment of the series, which ran from January to April 1911, was on the news stands when Cook returned to America in late December 1910 (picture above). Although this sequence of events has been decried as one of the most dastardly deeds in the history of journalism by Cook’s proponents, actually, beyond the contradictory doubts expressed in the first of four articles, the material published by Hampton’s was largely incorporated into Cook’s eventual book, My Attainment of the Pole, so his subsequent renouncement of the articles was only partially sincere. Only the last installment found no place in the book. In denouncing the articles in 1911, Dr. Cook confirmed this: “The articles that eventually appeared in Hampton’s, with the exception of unauthorized editorial changes and excisions of vitally important matter concerning Mr. Peary, were practically the same as planned in London. From a business standpoint, it was a poor decision. Hampton lost even more money as a result, forcing his magazine into receivership the next year.

Uncategorized

Where’s Waldo?

December 22, 2010

If you followed this blog last year during the centennial of the Polar Controversy, you may have wondered why there have been no recent posts. That long silence corresponds exactly to the period of time—more than a year—that Frederick A. Cook kept silence. It was on this day, 100 years ago that the world officially remade his acquaintance.

After Cook disappeared in late November 1909, his whereabouts became an enduring interest for the American press. A thousand dollars was offered simply for his address. Editorials wondered out loud how a man whose face was recognizable to millions internationally because it had appeared in the newspapers every day for months could have disappeared without a trace. Many reports of him were made from places as far flung as Peranmbuco or Jerusalem, but no proven sighting took place until October 1910, when Cook gave an exclusive interview to a reporter from the New York World in shabby hotel room near London’s theatre district. “My work is not dead nor, as some would wish, am I,” he declared.

In that interview the Doctor gave an outline of where he had been in the last year (mostly in Latin America) and openly doubted that Peary had reached the North Pole based on his incredible speeds after he left his last reliable witnesses.  He said he would soon make up for his long silence and give “a full answer to everything, and I will deliver it in my own time.”

“I shall be leaving London presently but only to perfect my plan to fight for my own at the proper time and place,” he warned.

And so he did. On December 22, 1910 in co-ordination with the first of a series of articles appearing in Hampton’s Magazine called “Dr. Cook’s Own Story,” he arrived in New York aboard the North German Loyd steamer George Washington. The scene that ensued “ was so promising of at least half a dozen fist fights that the oldest and most blasé ship news reporter hugged himself with delight a the prospect” as “men called each other liars to their faces . . . and women stood on chairs and joined vociferously in the arguments shouted by the men on both sides of the question of whether or not Dr. Cook had reached the pole, and whether or not he had been ostracized on his ‘return from Elba.’”

One of the horde of reporters that were on the dock to welcome the “Gumdrop Explorer” home noted, “He wore the same grin, the same sly twinkle in his eyes that he had when he fooled the public of New York and stood bowing to its cheers, his neck garlanded with a huge horseshoe of roses. Needless to say there were no garlands for the Doc last night; no shrieking whistles of acclaim; no frock-coated Aldermen; no big cheering crowds. The only thing that might be regarded as a decoration peculiarly applicable to the Doc’s vicinity were the Yuletide drapings of the George Washington’s main saloon, for these were of evergreen goods.”

The Doctor wouldn’t answer many questions, but he did respond when asked about his immediate plans. “I am through with exploration” he declared. “I have had enough. I am here to settle down as an American citizen.” Would he be challenging Peary to a debate over who first reached the Pole? “Certainly not. Impossible!” he protested. “Why impossible?” the reporter persisted. “Why, it is not my way,” Cook exclaimed.

But that was decidedly not the case. He had in mind already what he stated to the reporter in London, “I did not run away from my task, but from the intolerable conditions that were created to ruin it and to goad and harass me. What I so dearly earned may have been filched from me, but only temporarily. It will come to me just as I shall come back.”

Yes, Dr. Cook was now back, and his plan was soon set in motion.

News

The Doctor’s Danish Denouement.

December 21, 2009

Discovered!

The Copenhagen Decision

Today is the hundredth anniversary of what the newspapers called “The Copenhagen Decision.”   It marked an end to Frederick Cook’s credibility in most people’s minds.

In September, when he accepted its honorary doctorate, Cook had promised the University at Copenhagen that he would submit his “proofs” that he had been first at the North Pole, and these had been delivered by his private secretary in early December.  On December 16, the commission of Danish experts had sat to consider them.

They consisted of two documents: one was a typewritten report, 61 pages in length, substantially a repetition of the narrative that had been published in the pages of the New York Herald.  The other was said to be a complete and exact copy of the entries written in one of Cook’s notebooks between March 18 and June 13, 1908, the time Cook said he was on his way to the Pole and back again, covering 16 additional pages.  None of Cook’s original notebooks were submitted for examination. The Danes found that the typewritten information contained no original astronomical observations whatsoever, only results.

In just one day, the Danes announced, the “Commission singly had acquainted themselves with the material received and so had convinced themselves that it was entirely valueless for the determination of the question, whether Dr. Cook had reached the Northpole.”

Today, a century ago, the long-anticipated official decision of the University of Copenhagen on the data submitted by Frederick Albert Cook to prove he had reached the North Pole on April 21, 1908, was released.  It consisted of just 50 words:

“In accordance with this declaration of the expert Commission, the Konsistorium wishes to state, that the material which has beeen submitted the University for investigation, does not contain observations or information which could be considered to prove that Dr. Cook had reached the Northpole on his last polar trip.”

The New York Times headlined that Cook had no observations of his own and had used those manufactured by August Loose, even though the report explicitly stated that there were no observations whatsoever, but only results.  If the Dunkle-Loose affair had been an attempt at entrapment, it had failed.  But the lack of observations shocked Cook’s supporters almost as much as if he had used false data.

When the University was presented the actual notebook from which the submitted data had been copied, it did nothing to change the experts’ opinion.  In fact, they hinted, the physical arrangement of the book led them to conclude that the narrative it contained was itself a fabrication.  To make sure there would be no future embarrassment for Denmark, they secretly made a photographic copy of the entire book before returning it to Cook’s private secretary.

The official printed report of the University was more explicit: “There is in the documents submitted to us a not permissible lack of such guiding information which could show the probability that the mentioned astronomical observations had actually been undertaken; neither has the more practical side of the question, the sleigh trip, been described by such details which could help control the report.  The commission is therefore of the opinion that there can not in the material which has been submitted to us for examination, be found any proof whatsoever of Dr. Cook having reached the Northpole.”

In the wake of the Copenhagen Decision, a shower of abuse descended on the doctor from all quarters.  Editorials coast to coast called him Ananias, Munchausen, a “thimble-rigger,” a “contemptable cheat,” and a “monster of duplicity.”   Some editors were more temperate, holding out hope that Cook had believed he had reached the Pole, but he had somehow been mistaken.   The Newark Evening News commented:

“Whatever the future may bring forth is hidden, but now the popular decision must be that Dr. Cook is a faker of colossal assurance.  If he did reach the pole, it is pitiatble that he should be so discredited. If he did not, it is pitiable that a man’s thirst for fame should drag him to such depths.  If the first is true, he, largely by his won fault, is a terribly wronged man.  The only other alternative is that he has shamefully wronged his Nation and the nation that trusted him.”

Editorial cartoonists had a field day at Cook’s expense.  Here are a few examples of the many hundreds that were published:

Cook fell into the soup

Too much for the Baron

Well that's overFinis

In all of the outcry, only Cook’s voice was not heard.  He had vanished completely, and no one seemed to know his whereabouts, or would for nearly another whole year.

News

Enter Dunkle and Loose.

December 9, 2009

dunkle-and-loose

The paper that does things

Today the New York Times enjoys a preeminent place in American media, and this day marks the hundredth anniversary of a little known media event that could be said to mark the beginning of the upward rise of the paper to its current status.  On this day in 1909 the Times devoted nearly three whole pages to the individual affidavits of two unknown men:  one an insurance salesman named George H. Dunkle, and the other an itinerant Norwegian sea captain, August W. Loose.  In two separate sworn statements, they claimed to have been hired by Frederick A. Cook to manufacture a set of astronomical observations that would deceive the scientists at the University of Copenhagen, who had agreed to examine Cook’s “proofs,” that he had reached the North Pole on April 21, 1908.

This was a master stroke in the ongoing Polar Controversy, and it is no exaggeration to say that the prestige the paper gained by ultimately coming out on the winning side in the great dispute between Cook and Peary contributed largely to its ascent and the eventual decline of the New York Herald, which had backed Cook.  As one commentator put it at the time, “The great victory won by the New York Times in the polar controversy … is recognized… the world over … as making more firm the reputation of the Times as a newspaper that does things.”

But there were others suspicious of just how much the Times had actually “done” in obtaining these affidavits.  “It must not be forgotten,” reminded the Rochester Post-Express, “ that the paper publishing the story has been bitterly opposed to Dr. Cook from the beginning.  We do not insinuate that the New York Times would deliberately print a false story against Dr. Cook, but under the circumstances it is conceivable that the paper might fall a victim to such adventurers as Dunkle and Capt. Loose.  If the story prove false, then there is some truth in [the] charge that a conspiracy is at work against the explorer.  If it prove true, then the most charitable conclusion would be that Dr. Cook is a madman.”

The Nation agreed, but noted: “The affidavits are so circumstantial that it is difficult to doubt their truthfulness, but why did Cook fail to pay them their price, when the betrayal of the secret was sure to follow?  There is more in all this than is natural.”

The Dunkle and Loose affidavits did, indeed,  ”prove true” in all circumstantial aspects that could be independently verified.  Yet, the suspicions of how the New York Times got the story seem to have been justified,  since William C. Reick, the Times’ city editor, may have been the one who put the two up to it.   His motive?  He bitterly hated his former boss, James Gordon Bennett, owner of the Herald, and wanted revenge for his treatment at Bennett’s hands by discrediting Cook, whom the Herald had been booming in its pages for weeks.

Some editors, who saw a connection between the Times’ scoop and the enmity it had shown Cook from the start, suspected as much, since they could scarcely believe that Cook would enter into so risky an arrangement with total strangers.  To them, that possibility seemed preposterous, the alternative monstrous, and the conclusion obvious: “Dr. Cook is either the greatest and at the same time stupidest charlatan who ever attempted to impose upon a skeptical world, or he is the victim of the most malignant and devilishly ingenious persecution that hatred and envy could devise,” the Philadelphia Record opined.  ”Last week it was still the thing to maintain that the astute doctor could have made up a perfect set of polar observations, 800 miles form the pole, while wintering in an arctic igloo; this week the same doctor is suddenly transformed into such a pitiful ignoramus that Dunkle and Loose become his indispensable $4,000 aids in the forging of the precious records.  Doubtless the Danes have perspective enough to see the uproarious absurdity of the contrast,” concluded the Springfield Republican.

Time would soon tell, however, which speculations were correct, because Cook’s “proofs” had already been delivered to the Danish scientists and were locked away in a bank vault in Copenhagen when the Dunkle and Loose affidavits were published.  The question now was: did they contain Loose’s alleged forged data, or not?

All those who had followed the Polar Controversy for more than three months, now awaited for the Danish decision.

News

Polar Record article now available online.

October 23, 2009

The full text version of the article detailing the recovery of Frederick A. Cook’s original telegram drafts announcing that he had attained the North Pole is now available online.  If the link does not work, simply Google Frederick Cook telegrams.

News

Honor upon honor, allegation upon allegation, and a lost medal found.

October 15, 2009

Frederick Cook in NYA Busy Week

A hundred years ago, this was a busy week in the Polar Controversy.   Peary’s long awaited “proofs” that Dr. Cook had not been to the North Pole were released in the form of a statement alleged to have been made by the two Inuit who accompanied him, along with a map on which they were said to have traced his actual route, which indicated he had turned back when still in sight of land.  This map had been sent to newspapers around the country by the Associated Press on October 4 with the instructions:

Peary's map“Editors: The foregoing map is for use in connection with Robert E. Peary’s statement and it is to be held until this statement reaches you and is released.  This statement will be mailed or telegraphed in time for publication with the map in morning papers of Wednesday, Oct. 13.”

It was signed Charles S.Diehl, Assistant General Manager, The Associated Press.

Barrill Affidavit

The next day, the other shoe fell in the form of an affidavit by Edward N. Barrill, Cook’s only companion on his attempt to climb Mt. McKinley in Alaska in 1906.  It said Cook’s claim to have succeeded in this was a complete fraud and that the famous picture of himself standing atop the summit a fake taken miles away from the great peak and many thousands of feet lower than the actual summit.

On October 15, Barrill’s entire diary was published by the New York Globe.  It seemed to corroborate Cook’s story of a successful climb, but Barrill said those passages had all been dictated by Dr. Cook to bolster his contemplated narrative of a fake ascent.

Cook had already been honored on September 23 by a monster dinner at the Waldorf Astoria by The Arctic Club of America, had raked in more than $3,000 ($60,000 today) for his first lecture at Carnegie Hall, and had been honored in city after city in which he lectured on his polar attainment.

But the greatest honor was scheduled for October 15, where he was to be given the Keys to the City of New York in the aldermanic chamber of city hall.  No American had ever been so honored, and not even the sensational charges of Edward Barrill persuaded the aldermen to postpone the ceremony.

Cook with honor guard

He was escorted to the chamber by a honor guard of New York Police, who kept back the big crowd.  Once inside, he was first presented with a 2 ½ inch gold medal by a representative of the Arctic Club, whose medal had not been ready in time for presentation at the dinner in September.

Cook receives his scroll

Then Cook stepped forward to receive a mahogany box containing a 15 x 23 inch engrossed scroll of vellum representing the honor being given him by the city.  On the illuminated scroll were represented his igloo at the North Pole, a team of dogs pulling a sledge, and his expedition ship riding at anchor in the distance.  At its top rested the Seal of the City of New York upon two draped American flags.  The first initial of Cook’s name held the figure of Columbia seated on a throne, holding aloft a laurel wreath about to be placed on the explorer, clad in furs and holding a flag.  The inscription began “Whereas the mystery of the ages has been solved. . . “  It was signed by the mayor.

Sullivan Co Historical SocietyThe scroll still exists and is on display at the Sullivan County Historical Society in Hurleyville, New York.

The whereabouts of the medal was unknown until it was uncovered in the collections of the Missouri Historical Society in St. Louis in 2005.  How it ended up there is not apparent.  The society’s records only showed that it was donated to them by an anonymous patron in 1914.

Arctic Club medal obverse

This photograph of the medal appears on the website of the Frederick A. Cook Society, where it can be viewed for an enlargement of its details.

Uncategorized

How the Conquering Hero came

September 21, 2009

On September 21, 1909, Dr. Frederick Albert Cook arrived in the United Sates from Europe aboard the Oscar II. The liner had lain off Fire Island since three in the afternoon the day before so as not to upset the welcome plans for the Discoverer of the North Pole. She dressed in flags and proceeded to quarantine at midnight and at dawn was surrounded by boats of the press and well wishers.

Oscar II

Only one old friend was allowed aboard. Cook spoke to others from the rail.

Cook arriving on Oscar II

Cook transferred to the a tug which bore his wife and children and a half hour later boarded an excursion ship sent by the Arctic Club to greet him. A tumultuous scene ensued on the deck as the 423 passengers mobbed him, crushing the wreath of white tea roses the daughter of the secretary of the club put around his neck. An honor guard to the 47th regiment made sure Dr. Cook did not suffer the same fate.

Cook in roses

After sailing up the Hudson to kill time before the scheduled parade, the explorer disembarked to the blast of every ship and factory whistle in the harbor, and a cordon of 100 police officers forced a path to an awaiting car, the first of 200 assembled, whose horns took up where the ships whistles had left off.

Cook with family arriving in Brooklyn

Along the parade route an estimated 100,000 people stood, including many school children waving tiny flags and shouting “Cook! Cook!” as he stood in the back of his car and acknowledged them by doffing his derby.

Cook's old homestead

At the corner of Myrtle and Willoughby Avenues, directly in front of the three story brownstone mansion Cook had lived in before he left Brooklyn for the Arctic, stood a huge triumphal arch made of wood covered with canvas as high as the El viaduct next to it. Surmounted with laurel wreaths and garlands, it bore a giant golden globe with a flag flying form its very top. It dripped with painted ice cicles and electric lights and was decorated with arctic scenes, shields, more flags and a portrait of Cook, crowned with the words “We Believe in You.” Four snow white pigeons were released as the doctor’s car passed under the archway.

Cook's car under his triumphal arch

The parade ended at the Bushwick Club, where Cook rested and met with his backer, John R. Bradley, before he was forced to greet nearly 5,000 admirers at the public reception before the doors were closed on thousands more that waited their turn to hail the conqueror of the North Pole. Then followed a dinner, speeches, a serenade by a Brooklyn singing group and another reception.

At 9.30 the doctor was whisked away out a side door and taken to his rooms at the Waldorf-Astoria.

In summing up the dramatic day, the press expressed surprise that despite the huge crowds, only a few women and children had been slightly trampled, and even more amazing, with more than 200 automobiles on the street at once, there had not been a single accident.

Throughout it all, the object of all this adulation, as the New York World reported, remained calm and collected:

“His rugged nature, concealed beneath an aspect of constant smiles, seems as nearly unemotional as it is possible to conceive.

“Not even when the melodramatic features of the welcome that was prepared for him gripped the nerves of spectators and brought unbidden tears to manly eyes did Dr. Cook appear to be touched. The crowds roared and stamped, whistles blew and horns honked, and several times the doctor was almost swept off his feet, but he showed no sign of great joy or pride. Behind his dancing blue eyes of shallow depth there lies either wonder power of self-control or an innate insensibility to the ordinary emotions.”

Uncategorized

In the wake of the Gold Brick: Polar partisans said to be victims of “motivational reasoning”; blog commentaries prove point.

September 10, 2009

September 10 is a notable day in the history of the Polar Controversy.

On that day in 1909, Dr. Frederick A. Cook, loaded down with nearly every honor the Danish nation could bestow, departed Copenhagen on the first leg of his journey back to America.  The one exception was the exclusive Dannebrog, or Gold Medal of Merit, which it was rumored the Danish King withheld at the last moment when he heard that Cook had cheated one of his subjects of $500 in gold on an earlier visit to Greenland.

Meanwhile, Peary had reached the telegraph station in Labrador several days before and sent out his first messages.  Among them were these:

COOK’S STORY SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN TOO SERIOUSLY.  The Eskimos who accompanied him say that he went no distance north.  He did not get out of sight of land.  Other men of the tribe corroborate their statements.  Kindly give this to all home and foreign news associations for the same wide distribution as Cook’s story.

Good morning.  Delayed by gale.  Don’t let Cook story worry you. Have him nailed.  Bert.

But it was on this day a hundred years ago that Peary sent this famous message:

Battle Harbor Sept 10

Do not imagine Herald likely be imposed upon by Cook story, but for your information Cook has simply handed the public gold brick.  He’s not been at the pole April 21, 1908, or any other time.  The above statement is made advisedly and at the proper time will be backed by proof.  Peary.

The New York Herald didn’t want to wait and instead asked for the “proof” immediately.  After all, it had paid $3,000 to Cook for his exclusive account and had devoted it’s entire front page to Cook’s discovery only eight days before.

bigscoop

The Herald had given Peary similar coverage on September 7:

Peary returns

When “proof” was not forthcoming, Peary pleading that he had only seen “fragmentary” and “contradictory” reports of Cook’s claims, the Herald editorialized:  “If the information he possess is too fragmentary and contradictory to permit of his controverting Dr. Cook’s story, it would have been, to say the least, more dignified to wait until he obtained the correct story before launching his charges.”

Ironically, in hurling his gold brick, Peary inevitably opened up his own unsupported claim to close scrutiny.  As the doubts on both sides mounted, Governor Joseph Brown of Georgia, after noting the close similarity of both explorers’ stories, quipped, “If Cook has handed us a gold brick, Peary has handed us a paste diamond.”  The governor’s words proved prophetic.

Did you know that Cook was a Democrat and Peary a Republican? No, really, it’s true.

Now, John Tierney, the New York Times science writer, in his Findings column for September 8 and an additional  post on his blog TierneyLab, recalls the dispute and the doubts, and then attempts to explain why each man had such devoted followers from the outset and why belief in the explorers’ claims lingers in a few even today.  He compares them to political partisans, describing both groups as victims of what psychologists call “motivational reasoning.”  Like the reality of Cook’s and Peary’s claim to the North Pole, he writes, it’s all in their heads and nowhere else.

Only a few blog comments show reasons unmotivated.

The comments sent to his blog posts seem to bear these comparisons out.  There are several written by haters of “the establishment,” taking any excuse to call any symbol of it, in this case the symbol being the New York Times, to task.  Many in the Polar Controversy were of a similar mindset and took their discontent out on Peary, seeing him as the establishment figure, and Cook as the little man being crushed in his big fight against it.  There are a few sane comments, but as many of the posts are just disconnected ravings.  Other comments address Tierney’s call for their candidate for the title of “Discoverer of the North Pole,” plugging their hero and proving  Tierney’s point.  He says one of he symptoms of motivational reasoning is that it allows its practitioners to “dispense with the facts” when confronted with evidence contradictory to what they wish to believe.  A number of votes for Discoverer of the North Pole are for neither Cook nor Peary, but for Matt Henson, who accompanied Peary on his trek.  These are perfectly willing to eliminate Peary, while dispensing with the obvious fact that if Peary was nowhere near the North Pole, then Henson could not have been near it either.  That’s because Peary is said to have missed the Pole by at least 100 miles, and by their own individual accounts, the two men were never more than a few miles apart at any time. This is motivational reasoning at it’s finest. Yet, even though the reasoning is inexplicable, it is consistently predictable.

September 9, 2009: the Cook Society discovers the North Pole (blogs).

Predictable too is that the usual suspects will put in an appearance, sooner or later.  Yesterday the Frederick A. Cook Society finally discovered the North Pole blogs and chimed in:

Why have “researchers” like Rawlins and Bryce ignored the field work and scholarship of the Russians of the last 30 or more years? One group–the Shapros [sic] have gone to the Pole on the ice cover and have followed Cook’s route up
McKinley

They have written books with English translation printings and participated in the Yale Club symposium of the Cook Centennial in May 2008 (ignored by the Times).

Motivated reasoning can be found where you look. I would love to have the same sociological journals examine Rawlins’ strange little mag, aptly called the Journal of Hysterical Astronomy, which expresses “a general disdain for those who do not agree with him” (Mr Bryce on Mr Rawlins).

— Russell W Gibbons

Gibbons is the Executive Director of the Frederick A. Cook Society, a small group of Cook family members and boosters dedicated to gaining “official recognition” for Cook’s claims through motivational reasoning.  Although Gibbons’s comment is attached to the blog post concerning the recovery of Cook’s telegram drafts, which mentions neither sociologists or Mr. Rawlins, it attempts to transfer the society’s characteristics to them and him.

Dispensing the facts.

Why have researchers “ignored” the field work and scholarship he mentions?  Because they were bought and paid for by the Frederick A. Cook Society.  Members of that exclusive body are quick to point out that the sworn statement of Cook’s climbing partner that he and Cook never climbed Mt. McKinley in 1906 is worthless because it was bought by Peary’s backers, but they won’t mention that they contributed to the “field work and scholarship” presented by Dmitry and Matvey the Shparo at several of their occasional get-togethers.  Researchers know Peary’s backers gave Edward Barrill $1,500 for his “expenses” related to swearing out his affidavit against Cook.  The check that paid him and others for testimony against Cook is still in Robert Peary’s papers at the National Archives II.  Perhaps Mr. Gibbons will reveal just how much money from the trust fund controlled by the Frederick A. Cook Society went to the Shparos for the “field work” they did that they now say exonerates Cook, and how much more they paid to have them present a paper on what they found using the society’s “grant” to the self-same society, and which then appeared prominently in the Frederick A. Cook Society’s publications as evidence in Cook’s favor?

Gibbons claims the New York Times ignored their centennial gathering in New York City in 2008.  Not so.  On the contrary, the NYT was the only news source that noted it at all (see my blog entry for September 1, 2009 below).  And it was not a “Yale Club symposium.” It was a Frederick A. Cook Society event for which they rented the Yale Club’s rooms, which you may do for your own event, if you wish.  Renting prestigous-sounding venues for such meetings is a recurring MO.  Just ask The Mountaineers, who are still denying that the society’s meeting held in their rented rooms to celebrate the 90th anniversary of the day Cook claimed he summited Mt. McKinley was an endorsement in any way by their orgainzation of Cook’s claim.

Honestly,  when presented with new evidence and better data,  sometimes you have to admit you were wrong.

As for Mr. Rawlins’s “strange little mag” anyone who wants to can examine it and judge for themselves if it is a serious publication, as Mr. Tierney’s blog has provided a link to its online version.  The name of the journal is DIO; but it is occasionally published under the sub-title given by Gibbons.  That’s a Rawlins joke, reserved for exposures of wildly aberrant scientific “findings,” “fieldwork” and “scholarship,” such as the Frederick A. Cook Society specializes in.

As to the quote from this author about Mr. Rawlins, that comes from my book, Cook and Peary, the Polar Controversy, Resolved, published in 1997.  That was my opinion then.  At that time, I had only data from Mr. Rawlins’s book, Peary at the North Pole: Fact or Fiction?, and two live appearances from which to make a judgment.  Although I still think his style of rhetoric and individual sense of humor sometimes works against his message, and have often told him so, I now have known him for more than a decade and I have a different opinion of him.  He is a very thoughtful person to whom Truth, whatever it is, means a lot, and because it does, he is one of the most honest persons I have ever known.  He has even been known to admit that he was mistaken.

This change of view came with more evidence.  But a change of view based on additional evidence will never come to some.  Evidence, “the facts” and even Truth itself doesn’t matter and can’t phase the motivational reasoners of the Frederick A. Cook Society.  To this day, 12 years after it was published, not one of its members has ever been able to contradict a single salient piece of the extensive documentary and circumstantial evidence presented in my book that shows, beyond a reasonable doubt, that their namesake never climbed Mt. McKinley or was ever within 400 miles of the North Pole.

Yet, as Mr. Tierney quotes, “There will be a Cook [and Peary, and Henson] party till the end of time.”  Anything is believable if you suffer from “motivational reasoning” or unreasonable motivations.

News

Cook’s original telegram drafts are recovered.

September 6, 2009

Full details appear in the October issue of Polar Record.

Volume 45, Issue 4

The unexpected recovery of the original drafts of Cook’s telegrams sent from Lerwick, Shetland Islands containing the claim that Cook had reached the North Pole on April 21, 1908, appears in full in the October number of Polar Record, a peer-reviewed scholarly journal published by Cambridge University Press, which is now available on line at its website. The news of their discovery was reported on September 2 by the New York Times‘ science writer, John Tierney, in his blog TierneyLab.

Those few pieces of torn paper might be said to embody the entire Polar Controversy itself, because Cook’s claim was untrue, and had they not been written, there would never have been any controversy at all.

Second Draft

Cook’s second draft.

This is the second draft of Cook’s telegram he sent to the New York Herald, written on a standard UK telegram blank in the telegraph office in Lerwick on September 1, 1909.

News