From Hero to Humbug

This is the 21st in a series examining significant unpublished documents related to the Polar Controversy.
As we have already seen, the newspapers carried an account saying Ed Barrill had been bribed with $5,000 to make his affidavit against Cook, but that General Hubbard was quoted several times as denying he had received anything for [...]

This is the 20th in a series examining significant unpublished documents related to the Polar Controversy.
During the Barrills brief visit to New York, they swore out additional affidavits on October 14, 1909, concerning a letter Fanny claimed her husband had received from Dr. Cook, sent from Labrador in July 1907, but which had been misplaced. [...]

This is the 19th in a series examining significant unpublished documents related to the Polar Controversy.
On October 5, after he had taken affidavits from four others bedsides Barrill, Ashton wrote to General Hubbard, misdating his letter by a month as September 5.

Ashton had proposed to General Hubbard that Walter Miller bring the affidavits he had [...]

This is the 18th in a series examining significant unpublished documents related to the Polar Controversy.
In all of the Polar Controversy, perhaps the most telling piece of evidence produced against Frederick Cook’s claim to have discovered the North Pole had nothing to do with his 1908 polar expedition. It came instead out of his [...]

This is the 17th in a series examining significant unpublished documents related to the Polar Controversy.
Of all the bizarre incidents of the Polar Controversy, perhaps none has more unanswered questions surrounding it than the Dunkle-Loose affidavits. On December 7, 1909, the day after the so-called “proofs” of Dr. Cook’s polar attainment had been locked [...]

Happy 113th Anniversary of Dr. Cook’s non-arrival at the North Pole.
Of all the souvenirs that were marketed in the wake of the Polar Controversy, perhaps the most artistic are the porcelain items produced in Germany, then a leading exporter of such wares. The two character mugs have already been highlighted in the February 2022 [...]

In 1909, the rival claims of Cook and Peary to have reached the North Pole produced scores of individual postcards, many pairs of related designs and several series. By far the largest was that issued by Kawin & Co., mostly known for its stereopticon views, based in Chicago. It issued a series of [...]

Twenty-five years ago today, February 17, 1997, Cook & Peary, the Polar Controversy, resolved, was published.
I’d first taken an interest in the titanic dispute over who first reached the North Pole in the mid-1970’s and read the narratives Cook and Peary had written about their attainments of the North Pole. I also made an [...]

Among the handsomest items that was marketed in the wake of the Cook-Peary dispute were small portrait mugs of the explorers made in Germany. Germany was the leading exporter of inexpensive bisque and decorative pottery items at the beginning of the 20th century.
The mugs are made of glazed pottery and hand decorated. The one of [...]

Dr. Cook returned to America aboard S. S. Oscar II after a week of adulation in Denmark. At half-past midnight the ship proceeded to quarantine, arriving at 4 AM. There she was dressed in flags to meet the reception committee aboard The Grand Republic, chartered by the secretary of the Arctic Club, B.S. Osbon. [...]