[ Content | View menu ]

Archive

Cook & Peary, twenty-five years on

February 17, 2022

Cook book

Twenty-five years ago today, February 17, 1997, Cook & Peary, the Polar Controversy, resolved, was published.

I’d first taken an interest in the titanic dispute over who first reached the North Pole in the mid-1970’s and read the narratives Cook and Peary had written about their attainments of the North Pole. I also made an effort to read all the books that had been written about the dispute going back to Captain Thomas F. Hall’s pioneering analysis of 1917, Has the North Pole been Discovered? I had also read many magazine articles published during the controversy, so that I had a good grounding in the primary published sources on the subject. There things rested until the controversy was rekindled by a discovery in Peary’s papers at the National Archives in 1989 that seemed to indicate he had fallen far short of the Pole in 1909. With Peary’s claim in doubt, the claim of his rival, Dr. Frederick A. Cook to have beaten him to the Pole, though long discredited, received new attention.

I made contact with the Frederick A. Cook Society to see if access could be had to comparable papers of his discredited rival. I was told Janet Vetter, Cook’s only direct descendant, owned Dr. Cook’s papers, and after writing to her, I received a letter hinting that she might grant such access. But before I could arrange anything more concrete, Ms. Vetter died suddenly on August 10, 1989, at the age of 51. Under the terms of her will, her grandfather’s papers were to go to the Library of Congress, just 40 miles from my home.

When I read of the gift, I wasted no time in contacting the Library of Congress and was told that Vetter’s papers would be arriving sometime in early 1990. A further inquiry revealed, however, that there were no plans to catalog the papers in the near future, but that some of the most important ones, including Cook’s original field diaries had already arrived and could be seen by appointment. After I examined these, I urged the head of the manuscript division, Dr. James H. Hutson, to expedite processing of Cook’s papers, and by that Summer I was at work reading the entire gift.

Not far into this examination, I began a parallel examination of the vast Peary gift, housed just seven blocks away from the Library of Congress at the National Archives. For a person as steeped in the published Cook-Peary literature as I was, I quickly realized that despite all the previous articles and books already written on the Polar Controversy, there was much significant that had never been known about the dispute between the two explorers. I was certain that I could make an original contribution to the subject through a systematic and careful examination of these original materials. I decided then and there to write a book evaluating their content and how they related to the historical controversy and the larger question of it as an example of historical truth.

The result was published seven years later as Cook & Peary, the Polar Controversy, resolved. It was the fruit of three years of intensive research into not only the papers housed in Washington, to which I commuted three times a week for nearly six months, but also into just about every accessible collection of primary documentation on the subject, including a detailed reading of much of the massive printed literature, primary and secondary, personal interviews with living connections to the story, hundreds of letters of inquiry, tens of thousands of miles of travel and eventually eight years of writing and revision. All this primary material was documented by more than 2,400 source notes at the book’s end. By 1993 the manuscript, which filled an entire box of continuous-feed computer paper, was in reasonably good shape, and I set off on another three-year quest to find a publisher for it.

Many publishers were enthusiastic after they read my cover letter; they were less interested when they weighed my manuscript. Eventually, I sent only the first three chapters to Stackpole Books after getting a positive response to my proposal, avoiding mentioning the bulk of the whole manuscript. There I found an editor on the same page as I, Sally Atwater; she asked for three more chapters, and by the time she had read them, she was hooked. A contract was signed. But even as I prepared my manuscript for actual publication, new things came to light, new leads developed and new revisions were made as a result, some even after the galley proofs were printed.

The book got a lot of attention upon its release, with feature articles in the Washington Post ’s “Style” section and the US news section of the New York Times. These led immediately to a number of interviews, including segments the night of publication aired on ABC World News Tonight and MSNBC, and later, appearances on NPR’s The Diane Rehm Show and The World, as well as in two documentaries produced by the BBC.

Apparently, however, few absorbed the import of the new evidence I had uncovered, let alone that of the whole sweep of my 1,000+ page book, even those with prior knowledge of the subject or those who had the patience just to study my book thoroughly. It was dismissed out of hand, of course, by Cook’s partisans. They had convinced themselves that I was writing a book that would vindicate Cook and were shocked that it produced convincing evidence that he had lied about the results of his attempt to climb Mt. McKinley, and his real, but equally failed, attempt to reach the North Pole. But even some others scoffed at the subtitle, “The Polar Controversy, resolved.”

They may not have been Cook partisans, but they had some stake in wanting to see the controversy continue, like proprietors of “adventure” companies that promoted ultra-expensive “Last Degree” treks to the North Pole, and persons with some previous self-interest in justifying their version of the controversy that they had put into print, or others who simply liked to argue over it interminably. They said there would never be an end to the controversy, simply because there would never be possible to produce actual documentary evidence that proved Cook’s story a lie—the proverbial “Smoking Gun” that would end it, absolutely.

In the wake of my publication of Cook’s fake “summit” photo in DIO, following my recovery of it from a badly faded copy and its subsequent publication in the New York Times in 1998, Cook’s McKinley claim, that also still had its advocates even beyond The Frederick A. Cook Society, and which was called in mountaineering circles, “The Lie that Won’t Die,” finally breathed its last.

After my book was reviewed widely, reference after reference published subsequently cited Cook & Peary in their evaluation of the rival explorers’ claims. By the time of the centennial of the outbreak of the dispute between the two explorers in 2009, it had become a virtual consensus that certainly neither Cook nor Peary reached the Pole when he said he did, or ever. Even the National Geographic Society had nothing officially to say in support of Peary on the 100th Anniversary of his supposed attainment or to commemorate it, something they had never failed to do on any significant occasion in the past involving Peary’s alleged discovery.

Even the publication of what was, in effect, a feeble rewrite of Andrew Freeman’s The Case for Doctor Cook, that appeared in 2005 under the title True North, did nothing to stem the tide of dismissing Cook’s polar claim out of hand, as it had been early on, reversing the trend of a more positive consideration of Cook’s polar attempt in the light of the collapse of Peary’s claim.

However, my subsequent publication of The Lost Notebook of Dr. Frederick A. Cook in 2013, which closely analyzed a notebook whose existence had been unknown to scholars before the publication of Cook & Peary, finally provided the “Smoking Gun” that skeptics doubted would ever be produced, proving Cook could not possibly have reached the North Pole in 1908. Between the two books, the greatest geographic controversy in history, The Polar Controversy, had finally and truly been resolved.

Uncategorized

Dr. Cook Artifacts 4: The Portrait Mug

January 17, 2022

IMG_0837

Among the handsomest items that was marketed in the wake of the Cook-Peary dispute were small portrait mugs of the explorers made in Germany. Germany was the leading exporter of inexpensive bisque and decorative pottery items at the beginning of the 20th century.

The mugs are made of glazed pottery and hand decorated. The one of Dr. Cook is based on a widely published photograph of him from 1894.Cook It shows him in a fur outfit, fully bearded. The mug shows his right, mitted hand holding a pair of binoculars. At its bottom it has “COOK’ inscribed in block letters.

IMG_0841

The Peary mug is based on a photograph taken about 1898 showing him in a seal-fur hat and fur coat. Peary He has a small pouch strapped across him which he is clutching with his left hand, and a curved brown object in his pocket. Just what this object is supposed to represent is not obvious. “PEARY” is inscribed at the bottom.

IMG_0842

Each mug stands about 5 inches tall and is about 4 inches at the broadest. They hold about 10 oz. of liquid. That these two were issued as a pair is not only obvious from their common design but from the positioning of the arms so they can be stood next to each other in a balanced array.

IMG_0833

The back of the mugs have the inscription “Germany” and a style number. The Cook mug is #5568 and the Peary #5569. They also say “Déposé” and “Ges. Gesch;” “depose” means “deposit” in French; “gesh” is an abbreviation for Geschützt, which means “protected” in German. Both are similar to “Copyright” in meaning, and might be translated as “legally protected.” No maker is indicated.

There is a similar portrait mug of William Howard Taft. Whether it is directly related to the explorers’ mugs is doubtful. It’s style number is #5440, indicating it was made in advance of the ones of Cook and Peary. Taft assumed the presidency on March 4, 1909, six months before the start of the Polar Controversy, so the mug was probably issued to commemorate Taft’s inauguration. The close similarity in style and coloring indicate that Taft’s mug was issued by the same company, however. Instead of just saying “Germany” on the back, it says “Made in Germany Ges Gesch 5440 Déposé.”

IMG_0840

Although probably unrelated to the Cook and Peary mugs, the Taft makes a fine show standing as a buffer between the two rival explorers.  Considering the relative frequency the Peary comes onto the market compared to the Cook indicates that the Cook mug is far, far more scarce.

Uncategorized

Dr. Cook Artifacts 3: Welcome Home, Dr. Cook, September 21, 1909

December 9, 2021

Welcome 0

Dr. Cook returned to America aboard S. S. Oscar II after a week of adulation in Denmark. At half-past midnight the ship proceeded to quarantine, arriving at 4 AM. There she was dressed in flags to meet the reception committee aboard The Grand Republic, chartered by the secretary of the Arctic Club, B.S. Osbon. During the night a number of boats bearing newspaper men tried to board the ocean liner, but were unsuccessful. The best they could do was shouting questions at Dr. Cook who was standing at the gangway as he awaited the arrival of his wife, Marie, and children, Ruth and Helen, aboard the tug John K. Gilkinson.

Welcome 01

At dawn, as the tug approached, the Gilkinson was accompanied by a number of boats including the New York Herald’s dispatch boat Owlet. The Herald was then running a serial of Dr. Cook’s narrative of his expedition. As the tug came along side, Cook descended the rope ladder and leapt to its deck. For half an hour the tug lay dead in the water while Dr. Cook visited with his family in the cabin, while the passengers on the Oscar II broke out into a chorus of “For he’s a jolly good fellow.”

The Grand Republic soon appeared, and at 9 AM Dr. Cook and his party transferred to the steamer, which was visibly listing to one side from the weight of its 424 passengers lining the deck rail.

Welcome 02

In this postcard view, left to right are: The Grand Republic, John K. Gilkinson, Owlet, and Oscar II.

Welcome 04

It was planned that the doctor would pass through an honor guard of the 47th Regiment, where he was supposed to be met with a wreath of white tea roses, to be placed ceremoniously around his neck by Miss Ida A. Lehmann of Brooklyn, daughter of the secretary of the Dr. Cook Celebration Committee of 100. As it was, the honor guard in their white and blue dress uniforms were too busy trying to help Captain Osbon keep the guest of honor from being crushed to death to perform their designated function, and Miss Lehmann barely managed to lasso the doctor with the wreath, which itself was soon crushed to lifelessness as he was buffet around on the deck by the happy crowd.

welcome 03

Cook managed to take refuge on the hurricane deck, from which he gave a short speech that was all but inaudible over the shrieking whistles of all the ships in the harbor that had been assembled for a naval parade as part of the Hudson-Fulton Celebration.

It was now 9:30, and the reception was not set until noon, so to kill time The Grand Republic cruised slowly up the North River as far a Spuyten Duyvil, then docked briefly at 130th street to let off some of its passengers before passing back down the river. After one more turn, she docked at Williamsburg’s South Fifth Street wharves below the sugar refineries to a tremendous cheer from the thousands waiting on shore, accompanied by a great blast of whistles from the factories and the ships on the river.

With the assistance of 100 police officers, Cook’s party struggled through an estimated crowd of 5,000 on the wharf to enter a car to start a parade, led by a flatbed truck with a brass band, to start along the five-mile route to the Bushwick Club, where the official reception was to be given.

Welcome 05

Left to right: Bird Coler (with hat in hand), Brooklyn Borough President, B.S. Osbon, Ruth Cook, Dr. Cook, Mrs. Cook; William Cook, his brother, stands behind the policeman.

welcome 08

Along the parade route stood 100,000 people. It seemed everyone in the whole borough was in the streets, and as he passed along, Cook acknowledged their plaudits by raising his hat, smiling and bowing.

Welcome 10

Welcome 12As the procession turned the corner directly opposite his old home on Bushwick Ave., the doctor caught sight of the triumphal arch erected by his neighborhood association over the intersection of Myrtle and Willoughby. It was a huge canvas and wood frame structure as high as the El viaduct next to it. Surmounted with laurel wreaths and garlands, it bore a giant golden globe with a flag flying from its top. It dripped with painted icicles and electric lights and was decorated with arctic scenes, shields, more flags, and a portrait of Cook crowned with the words “We Believe in You.” Four snow white pigeons were released as the doctor’s car passed under the archway by a man atop the arch. (both sides of the arch are shown here)

Eventually the motorcade of 200 autos reached the flag-enshrouded Bushwick Club and as the police kept back the crowds, Cook alighted from his car and entered the club. He appeared briefly on the building’s balcony, but despite cries for a speech, he could not be heard and once again simply bowed.

Then, after a light lunch, the doors of the Club were opened, and more than 5,000 passed by the doctor. He could not shake hands with so many, however, so he kept them firmly clasped behind his back as he nodded to each passerby. After three hours the doors of the club were closed to the disappointment of thousands more waiting to get in. Dr. Cook’s day ended at 9:30 PM, with a formal dinner at the club before finally retiring, under police escort, to a suite reserved for his family at the Waldorf-Astoria.

welcome 14

Cook’s momentous day produced very few souvenirs. In fact, the only one I have ever seen is this small celluloid pinback that was doubtless hawked to the enormous crowd waiting for Cook to pass by. Other than that, only some hastily prepared postcards were produced and sold after the events of the day.

Welcome 13

This one from the author’s collection is inscribed by Dr. Cook in his distinctive handwriting to a man sharing his given name, “Best Regards from another Fred,” and dated October 3, 1909.

Welcome 09

Another showing Cook’s former home on Bushwick Ave. taken from the El viaduct above it and the triumphal arch spanning the street below, was also on sale a few days after the parade.

While Cook was off on his polar expedition, Cook’s wife was forced to sell their  three-storey red brick house when her considerable personal funds were lost in the collapse of the Knickerbocker Trust Co. during the Panic of 1907. However, it still stands today on Bushwick Ave., where it is divided into several apartments. Shortly after the parade, it was announced that on the small triangular plot across from it, a monument to the Discoverer of the North Pole would be placed, but due to Cook’s downfall, it was never built. Instead, a monument to the fallen of World War I now occupies that space.Welcome 16

Uncategorized

Dr. Cook Artifacts 2: The Esquimaux pitchers

November 10, 2021

1

In the summer of 1893, after his return from Greenland where he had been surgeon to Peary’s North Greenland Expedition, Frederick Cook was hired to be “guide” for a tour of Greenland aboard the yacht Zeta. The ship had been chartered by a Yale professor on behalf of his half-addled son, who had developed an uncontrollable obsession with the notion of seeing the Far North after hearing Peary speak of his experiences there at one of his lectures the previous winter. It was on this voyage that Cook first conceived of an American Antarctic Expedition with himself as its leader. To that end he traded for fur garments and dogs while in the Danish settlements. But how to finance it?

When the Zeta touched at Rigolet, Labrador, he met an Inuit man who worked for the Hudson’s Bay Co. who had two teenage children. Before the Zeta sailed Cook somehow persuaded the man to allow him to take the two, a 16-year old girl named Kahlahkatak, and a 14-year old boy named Mekok, back with him to the United States, promising to return them the following year. For convenience, Cook renamed his wards Clara and Willie.

Once back in Brooklyn he put the two children up at his brother’s house on Bedford Avenue. It wasn’t long before the New York newspapers carried amusing accounts of the first “full-blooded Eskimos” ever to visit America. The children were amazed by the tall buildings and feared the heights of the bridges. They detested ice cream, and complained about the weather being too cold. All the time, Dr. Cook continued to plan his assault on the nearly-unknown Antarctic continent.

Lecture 2

He petitioned the American Geographical Society for financial support, and when that was not forthcoming, he contracted with the famous impresario of the lecture platform, Major James B. Pond, for a series of lectures on his experiences in the Arctic and the curious culture of it’s inhabitants.

Throughout the winter Cook toured New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Massachusetts, at admission prices ranging from 25 to 75 cents, illustrating his lecture with a hundred stereo-opticon views of Greenland. At his appearances he exhibited some of his dogs and also Willie and Clara, got up as if they were “wild people” in fur costumes he had obtained in Greenland. He never mentioned that instead of an igloo, the two children lived with their parents in a civilized log house in Rigolet, but implied instead that they lived in the traditional Inuit style.

After the tour ended, Cook continued to exhibit at Huber’s Dime Museum at $300 a week, where he appeared nine times a day on a stage set up to look like and Inuit encampment. He populated this “village” with not only Willie and Clara, but also four of the ten Labrador Inuit who had been abandoned by their exhibitors after the close of the World’s Columbian Exhibition in Chicago the previous fall. His initial run of appearances at Huber’s was a big success, and the owner wanted him to continue longer, but Cook cut them short when one of the World’s Fair Inuit took sick and died.

Cook lectureTo supplement his income from his appearances, Cook had made up a large number of stoneware milk pitchers trimmed in gold and bearing a colored transfer image of either Mekok with a native dog, or Kahlahkatak holding a puppy, based on photographs he had used in his promotional literature for his lectures. These he sold as souvenirs, probably for 25 cents each. Judging by the proportions they turn up today, it appears that Kahlahkatak’s pitcher was the better seller. It seems about three times more common than Mekok’s pitcher.

Cook also was accompanied by Clara and Willie at lectures he gave to the New York Obstetrical Association and the Brooklyn Gynecological Society, at which he first described the hitherto unrecognized details surrounding the spacing of Inuit births and the seasonality of the menstrual cycle in Inuit women. As a result of these lectures, Cook was elected a member of the American Ethnological Association. He also took the children along when he entered some of his wolfish dogs into the Westchester Kennel Club show in 1894, winning three prizes there.

None of this produced either the kind of money or the backing he needed to attack the Antarctic fastness, however. So Cook hatched the idea of a “tourist jaunt” to Greenland in the summer of 1894 aboard the steamer Miranda for well-healed excursionists at $500 a head (about a $3,500 today), with famously disastrous consequences. The ship hit an iceberg, ran into a reef and foundered on the way home, but all the passengers were saved.

On the way out on that ill-fated voyage, Cook stopped again at Rigolet to return not only Willie and Clara, but also the nine surviving World’s Fair Inuit, who came from the same region of Labrador.

IMG_0405

Today, these sturdy  stoneware pitchers remain as lasting reminders of this little known early phase of Dr. Cook’s eventful career.

Uncategorized

Frederick Cook, M.D.: What it was to be a doctor in 1890

October 4, 2021

Cook_nel_1909

In too many instances modern interpretations of history ignore the true context of events. Individuals’ attitudes and actions are today often criticized or condemned because they do not conform to current thinking on social or moral norms. But to treat the past as if it were the present, completely distorts history and thwarts an understanding of the past as it was actually lived. Even the simple fact that Frederick Cook was a medical doctor must be put in the perspective of his own times without the intervention of current attitudes and expectations. Otherwise, without any historical context, many might ascribe attributes of social status or character now associated with being a medical doctor to him that would not have applied in Cook’s time.

In 1890, when Cook received his medical degree from New York University, the scientific basis of today’s medicine was barely understood even by its most advanced practitioners, and because of this doctors were hardly held in the high regard they are today. Most of America’s 57 million inhabitants then lived in rural areas, and farmers still far outnumbered laborers. Babies were mostly delivered at home by mid-wives, and outside the cities, hospitals hardly existed. In 1889 there were only 700 hospitals in the whole nation, and there were only fifteen nursing schools. Even in metropolises like Boston, hospitals were places where only the working poor, indigent or the insane received institutional care. The rest, from the middle class up, were treated at home, usually by a relative, or at best by someone who had some “medical” experience, perhaps during the Civil War. If a community had access to a “doctor,” he was often a self-proclaimed one, with perhaps some experience working with an actual physician. But even then, because there were few regulations on who could practice medicine, that might not be much of a qualification.

Many shunned doctors entirely, and for good reason. As Oliver Wendell Holmes of Harvard’s Medical School said at mid-century, “If the whole materia medica as now used, could be sunk to the bottom of the sea, it would be all the better for mankind—and all the worse for the fishes.” Through much of the 19th Century medical practice included such ancient practices as blood letting and harsh purging of the bowels. These treatments, though given in good faith, were based on misapprehensions of the causes of disease, which were often thought to arise from miasmas or imbalances of the humors within the body. Even Koch’s announcement of the Germ Theory in the 1870s, and his identity of the specific microbes that caused tuberculosis and cholera in the 1880s, and Pasteur’s proof that microbial agents were the cause of such diseases as anthrax were slow to take hold. It was one thing to identify the causative agent, another to discern a cure for the disease caused by it. Tuberculosis remained the number one killer of adults fifty years after Koch’s identification of its pathogen. Lister’s 1867 demonstrations that led to antiseptic techniques to avoid infection of wounds eventually revolutionized the surgical field, but they were also put into practice slowly, and effective antiseptic techniques did not become routine until the mid-1890s.

Despite the growing acceptance of Germ Theory, in 1890 the causes of epidemics of vector diseases like yellow fever, malaria and typhus remained unknown, and the treatments given them were futile. Poor sanitation, filthy, crowded living conditions in the cities and unprotected water supplies led to massive outbreaks of cholera, gastrointestinal and respiratory diseases. Typhoid fever, syphilis, malaria, measles and diphtheria commonly claimed those TB spared. Vaccination as a preventative to infection was limited to small pox, and it was usually employed only during an epidemic. Basically, before antibiotics, doctors had a reliable cure for almost nothing.

Life expectancy at birth was a little over 40 on the average, lowered by the frequency of death in infants and children who died in childbirth, or of measles, diphtheria, diarrhea, croup, pneumonia or scarlet fever. Those who survived past 40 could, however, expect to live on average to 65. But compared to today, few lived long enough to die of degenerative diseases such as heart disease or cancer.

As a result of the scarcity of rural physicians and a suspicion of their treatments, calling a doctor was a last resort after consulting with family, friends or perhaps a general storekeeper with a stock of patent medicines that often contained dangerous compounds such as arsenic, antimony, mercury or opium, or reliance on tonics whose only active ingredient was alcohol. There were no pure food and drug laws until 1906, and little regulation of drugs, either over the counter or prescription medications. Pharmacists actually competed with doctors in that they were allowed to fill any prescriptions once issued to a patient over and over, leading to sometimes inappropriate self-dosing.

Most state licensing laws did not come into force until the end of the 1880’s, and even then the best educated medical doctors had invested relatively little time in training compared to modern standards. A medical degree could be obtained in three years and the coursework consisted mainly of attending abstract lectures with little or no bedside or laboratory training. Entrance requirements consisted of being of “good moral character” and being 21 years of age. There were no formal educational requirements beyond grammar school. Dr. Cook’s course work at New York University was typical: two winter lecture series lasting six months each and a course in practical anatomy followed by passing written examinations in surgery, chemistry, practice of medicine, materia medica, anatomy, physiology and obstetrics. Practical examinations on a cadaver and demonstration of urinalysis competency were also required.

Their low standing placed most physicians outside of cities in a cash-strapped position. It was considered ordinary to carry at least 30% of owed bills on a deferred, “ability to pay” basis, and to accept in-kind payments in goods and services in lieu of cash. Even in the big cities pay for doctors was not high. In 1909 the average general practitioner in New York City earned $1,300 a year. In modern buying power that would amount to about $30,900 today. A common labor averaged about $500. Cook, like most other doctors of his time, had to work hard to establish a practice and struggle to retain the patients he did attract.

Cook felt it necessary to take a further private course in medical diagnosis after graduating. With little understanding of the underlying causes of disease, diagnosis lay at the heart of being a successful doctor in Cook’s time. Such aides as X-rays, electrocardiographs and diagnostic tests beyond urinalysis all lay in the future. The ophthalmoscope and laryngoscope were then considered the tools of specialists, and even the use of the stethoscope and the thermometer was not yet universal. Clues to the nature of the patient’s illness had to be obtained by sight and touch. As such, observational skills were critical. A doctor’s reputation and credibility rested squarely on his diagnostic and prognostic skills, which may account for Dr. Cook’s success as a physician. He was an acute observer.

The effective medicines the doctor prescribed were limited as well, and as already alluded to, often contained dangerous compounds. Few were without side effects or long term consequences. For pain or diarrhea concoctions containing opium, such as laudanum, were useful. Digitalis was prescribed to manage certain heart irregularities; quinine exerted an effect on malaria. A new drug, acetylsalicylic acid, later commonly called by its trade name, Aspirin, was found effective against fevers and rheumatism. Belladonna was used to treat asthma, whooping cough and cardiac disease; mercury compounds were commonly used against syphilis. Tincture of iodine was a common disinfectant. But like today, most patients equated being given a medicine with proof that something tangible was being done to address their ailment, and doctors of Cook’s time routinely carried a supply of sugar pills when they knew they had nothing effective to offer beyond satisfying this psychological need.

In Cook’s day, as did the ancients, physicians still considered environmental factors to play a large role in the onset and progress of diseases and sought to control them, for example, advising TB patients to move to a dry climate. The use of diet, tonics, and wines as “blood stimulants” were also considered part of good practice.

A glimpse into Cook’s use of the medicines at his disposal in the context of the knowledge and practice of his time can be gotten from the medical advice he wrote out for Peary just before his separation from him on Peary’s attempt to cross Greenland’s icecap in 1892:Cook quote

The invention of anesthesia using ether, chloroform or nitrous oxide, had made pain-free surgery possible, but major operations, which were usually performed outside of hospitals, remained rare due to the ongoing obstacle of post-operative infection until it was controlled through antiseptic technique. So the term “surgeon” by which Cook was known on the arctic expedition with Peary and with de Gerlache’s Belgian Antarctic Expedition, should not be equated with the common understanding of the term today. Cook was not trained or qualified to handle more than would be considered “minor” surgery today.

With such limitations of effective treatment and diagnostic technologies, the ability to inspire confidence in the patient and assure him he would recover was recognized as one of physician’s most powerful tools, and the “bedside manner” displayed by a doctor was often the determining factor in the selection and retention of a physician by prospective patients. In this area Cook was at a great advantage. His always cheerful, non-fussy, and compassionate behavior was noted by everyone who knew him. While other doctors so jealously guarded against losing their patients to other practices that they rarely took time off or entrusted their care to another doctor for even a short time, Cook was absent on his exploring adventures years at a time, yet when he returned his patients always came back to him.

The patient’s impression of Cook can be sensed from a quote by Admiral Winfield S. Schley, the hero of the Battle of Santiago in the Spanish-American War, that appeared in the Los Angeles Times on September 23, 1909, shortly after Cook returned to America from the Arctic and his claim to have been to the North Pole and his general veracity was being questioned. “Dr. Frederick A. Cook was for two years my wife’s physician,” said Schley. “I saw him two or three times a week, and we chatted many hours. If I have ever known a man of integrity, probity, sincerity and modesty, it is Dr. Cook.”

The astute perception of human psychology that made Cook able to nearly carry out the most audacious circumstantial geographical hoax ever attempted was just as instrumental in his success as a physician. He understood that “the passions” and psychological factors were often as important in medical recovery as actual treatment of illness in his time. He was ever encouraging to his patients as, for example, in alleviating the depression now known as Seasonal Affective Disorder that ran rampant among his shipmates during the first overwintering within the Antarctic Circle aboard the Belgica.

As Roald Amundsen, who was the Belgica’s second officer, attested in his book My Life as an Explorer: “It was in this fearful emergency, during these thirteen long months in which almost the certainty of death stared us steadily in the face, that I came to know Dr. Cook intimately. He, was the one man of unfaltering courage, unfailing hope, endless cheerfulness, and unwearied kindness. When anyone was sick, he was at his bedside to comfort him; when any was disheartened, he was there to encourage and inspire. And not only was his faith undaunted, but his ingenuity and enterprise were boundless.”

His acute powers of observation led him to correctly conclude that a major contributing factor was a lack of sunlight during the Antarctic winter and led his to prescribe a crude form of light therapy, placing them before an open fire as a substitute. He also set an example and always found words to give them hope, the best medicine of all.

This understanding of human nature and the power of the mind over the body was enhanced by his contact with primitive cultures, such as that of the Greenland Inuit, where he observed the power of the native shamans to distract, comfort and sometimes “cure” their “patients” solely by elaborate ritual practices that convinced them they would recover.

Only with all this in mind, can we have a truer picture of Cook’s actual status in his time and avoid the pitfalls of “presentism” and avoid judging the past by modern standards and experience, which would impute to him a much higher status than he actually enjoyed and that his professional training had endowed him with intellectual achievement and scientific acumen that under its then comparatively sketchy requirements he did not necessarily possess. It also avoids the assumption that being a doctor conferred on him a high degree of ethics and moral standing that many now impute to his profession and so would make him less vulnerable to resorting to deceit and dishonesty.

This survey of the state of medicine in Cook’s time is largely based on the article “What it was like to be sick in 1884,” by Charles E. Rosenberg, that appeared in American Heritage, volume 35, number 6, published in 1984.

The quotation from Cook’s medical instructions to Peary can be found among the records of Peary’s first Greenland Expedition of 1891-92, which are part of the Peary Family Collection housed at the National Archives and Records Administration II, College Park, MD.

Uncategorized

Dr. Cook Artifacts 1: The Cook Statuette

September 27, 2021

IMG_0550

The Polar Controversy spawned an avalanche of items designed to take advantage of the intense public interest in the dispute between September and December 1909. Most of these were ephemeral items, but they were so numerous that many of them have survived. One such item was a statuette of each of the two explorers that was designed to be sold at newsstands in New York City. They are made of chalkware and cast on a metal armature that runs up through the figures’ legs. They were copyrighted by the Franklin Lithograph Co. of New York, which was located at E. 87th Street.

IMG_0549

The sculpts are signed “Geo. Magnani” on the reverse. The statuettes are very similar in pose, but not identical, the main difference being the details of the face so as to distinguish between the two explorers. Each has alliterative attributed characteristics of the explorer encompassed by the first letter of his last name on the globe beneath his feet, and a slogan on the base. Perhaps a bias toward Cook is conveyed by the chosen slogans. Cook’s reads “The Man Who Compelled Belief!”; Peary’s “I have nailed the Stars and Stripes to the North Pole. What Have You Nailed?”Peary statue 3

These statuettes are scarce today because of the cheap materials they were constructed of and are very seldom found intact. The relative number of them that have survived seems to indicate that they were put on sale early in the controversy and sold in relatively equal numbers.

Uncategorized

Inside the Peary Expedition: Part 15: December 1912: Franke’s case against Peary is resolved

August 11, 2021

The case drug on for another three years. In June 1911, a commission was sent to Canada and the United States to investigate and take testimony from several witnesses including Joe White and Henry Johnson, mentioned in Franke’s complaint. Both men were originally members of the Roosevelt’s crew, but they and all other Americans were dismissed by Peary at Sydney, leaving only Newfoundlanders to man her. Both men, however, were hired on as Able Bodied Seamen on the Erik by Captain Sam Bartlett, and so made the trip to Etah aboard her in company with Peary’s ship. Both later gave affidavits attesting to Peary’s covetousness when it came to furs and ivory, and how he traded for them at great advantage, yet banned any member of either ship’s crew from bartering with the Inuit for the like, or anything else of value. An affidavit by each man was published in the October 1910 issue of Tourist Magazine in an article authored by B.S. Osbon. We can assume that their sworn testimony to the visiting commission was similar in content.

This same commission also interviewed Dr. Cook in New York. Cook had finally returned to America in December 1910 after an absence of slightly more than a year, during most of which his whereabouts were unknown. In a letter to Peary’s lawyer from his representative, Mr. Griffith, of the legal firm of Joline, Larken & Rathbone, dated June 15, 1911, he reported that the deposition was taken before himself and the commissioner, Mr. Schurz, in Franke’s presence. He reported that Cook testified that he had not initiated the suit. While under oath he got Cook to say, after some reluctance, that he was the Cook who claimed to have reached the North Pole in 1908, adding, “And I did go there,” much to the lawyer’s delight. As he put it, “If he is still willing to assert under oath that he went to the North Pole, I should not think that a German or any other Court would care very much what else he said.”

On December 13, 1911, Peary wrote this letter to his lawyer, Charles Nichols concerning the case:Peary 1911 letter 1

Peary 1911 letter 2Peary 1911 letter 3Others who were deposed were Walter A. Larned, who had been one of the paying “guests” on the Roosevelt, and Captain Bob Bartlett. B.S. Osbon, who was to testify, had, in the meantime, died. Victor Schneider, Peary’s German lawyer, didn’t think much of the testimony for the Plaintiff. In a letter dated June 23, 1912, to Peary’s lawyer, Charles J. Nichols, Schneider said, “Johnson’s testimony amounts to absolutely nothing and Joe White appears to be a weak witness for Franke, although his testimony shows much prejudice in the matter. Franke himself was present and at intervals made himself obnoxious by his attempts to assist his witnesses. I cannot see that Franke has as yet produced any testimony outside of his own statement, to support his action, except possibly Cook’s statement that half of the furs were Franke’s.
“Certainly there is not a line of testimony that would be competent or relevant under our rules of evidence to show that any furs belonging to Cook or Franke were ever received on board either the ‘Roosevelt’ or the ‘Eric,’ and there is not a line of testimony as to any arrangements between Admiral Peary and Franke as to any demand made by Admiral Peary upon Franke.”

Franke tendered an oath for Peary to swear to, but then withdrew it, as he indicated he wished more witnesses to be deposed, including Peary, himself. However Schneider wrote to Nichols on January 16, 1913, advising Peary to ignore the withdrawal and sign the tendered oath. This he did, apparently backdating it to before the date of Franke’s withdrawal to December 9, 1912:

“I, Robert E. Peary, the defendant herein, swear {sic} before God, the Almighty and Allknowing that: ‘I did not tell the plaintiff in August 1908 at Etah, that I would only take him onto my ship “Eric” and return him to New York provided he would give me his entire collection of blue fox skins, navalhorns {sic} and walrus’ teeth, which the plaintiff and Dr. Cook co-jointly had collected, without any pecuniary consideration. SO HELP ME GOD.”

On the basis of this affidavit the case of Rudolph Franke v. Robert E. Peary, was dismissed by the German court. After all, the word of a man of the moral stature of Robert E. Peary under oath could not possibly be doubted.

The letters referred to and Peary’s sworn statement, along with many others items regarding the case are all at NARA II.

This is the last article in this series: “Inside the Peary Expedition.”

Uncategorized

Inside the Peary Expedition: Part 14: Aftermath: June 10, 1910: Franke sues Robert E. Peary

July 23, 2021

After the adverse findings of the commission appointed to examine Dr. Cook’s records at the University of Copenhagen in December 1909, and the superficial examination Peary’s records received by the National Geographic Society the previous month that resulted in a favorable verdict on his claim, Peary was generally acknowledged as the discoverer of the North Pole. After some preliminary lectures in the United Sates, he set off on a triumphal tour of Europe where he was honored and awarded gold medals and other honors. While staying at the Adlon Hotel in Berlin, however, he received something he didn’t want; he was served papers in connection with a suit brought by Rudolph Franke aimed at recovering the monetary equivalent of the furs and other belongings he claimed Peary had extorted from him at Etah in August 1908.

In connection with this suit Franke filed the following deposition:

“To carry out Dr. Cook’s orders, the complainant transferred the things from Annatok {sic} to Etah and from there to Arwagluari-Po[i]nt. This last point was especially difficult as it lead over the very dangerous glacier known as the Morris K. Jesup Glacier, partially melted by the sun. The complainant suffered from a serious sprain to one of his legs. In Arwagluari-Po[i]nt the complainant left his things together with a letter asking passing whalers or any other ship to take the same to New York. In this letter he said the things belonged to Dr. Cook and should be given to Mrs. Cook. The complainant returned to Etah and from there to North Star Bay in a boat. This is a station of the Whalers. Here he left news that he was sick, and any ship happening along the coast to take him aboard or to look for him in Etah, and after his return to Etah, he found there the defendant’s ship ‘Roosevelt’ which ship was joined next day by the Eric {sic}.

“In spite of the fact that the defendant had received the letter left by the complainant at North Star Bay, he offered no assistance. Proof that the complainant received letter as follow: Sworn to by witness Joe White 419 West 39th Street, New York City and for the articles left, testified to by Dr. Cook whose address will be given later.1 The defendant is required to swear the above is true. Furthermore the testimony of the witnesses named below to whom the complainant told the course of this Expedition and showed his drawings which same drawings were placed before the Cook Commission in Copenhagen.

“The defendant was not present when the complainant arrived in Etah, being off on a hunting trip. The physician of the Expedition cared for the complainant. Upon return of the defendant he asked the complainant if he had articles and if so where. This question was only put to give the impression that the letter left at North Star Bay by complainant had not been found by defendant. The Complainant told defendant which articles he had and where they were to be found. He also told defendant that Dr. Cook had requested him to bring these articles to N. Y. and that they belonged to Dr. Cook. Following is the list of the items: 200 blue fox skins valued at from 40 to 50 thousand mark, 7 pieces narwhal horns valued per piece 6 to 7 hundred mark [each], 2 dozen narwhal teeth2 valued 1000 mark Sworn and testified to by Joe White.

“The companion ship Eric was to return from Etah to N. Y. so the complainant asked that he and his articles be taken to N.Y. The defendant made reply that under no consideration would he transport his belongings but if he gave up his furs which the defendant needed for his Expedition he would allow him pass[age to] go on the ship. Testimony as before. Furthermore the defendant told the complainant he would try his utmost to find Dr. Cook. As the complainant was very ill and believed he would die shortly also that the defendant would use furs and narwhal horns solely for his expedition and because he believed that the defendant would do all possible in the interest of the complainant’s employer namely, Dr. Cook, he consented to have his belongings removed by the defendant’s Eskimos from Arwagluari-Po[i]nt. This was soon done and the defendant forced the complainant to give him his belongings on board the Roosevelt. He also forced him to write letters of August 11 and 13th, 1908.3 As compensation for his passage to N. Y. Complainant gave to defendant all his provisions of which he had goodly supply. Testimony as before.

“The complainant began his return on board the Eric and was bedridden the first few days. As he grew better, he learned the return of the Eric had been provided for by a Mr. Norton and that defendant had nothing to do with same. He further learned much to his surprise that many blue fox skins as well as narwhal horns were to be found on board the Eric. The complainant felt sure that he could swear that two narwhal horns were done up in the same packing in which he, the complainant had placed them and directed to the former President of the U. S., Roosevelt. Testimony as before. The complainant has learned that the defendant has made presents of blue fox skins given by the complainant to the following: Pres. Roosevelt, the present President Taft and Mrs. Taft, Capt. Sam Bartlett, Brigus Newfoundland, Mr. Craft from Carnegie Institute, Washington D.C., Edd Larned, 156 Broadway, N.Y. City, Frank Norton, 589 Exchange Place, 14 Etage, N.Y. city, Harry Whitney, Newhaven, Connecticut, U. S. A. In consequence of the above having received blue fox skins and they they {sic} were the same skins given to defendant by complainant the testimony of same will be taken. Mr. Sam Bartlett and Mr. White and crew of the Eric whose names will be given later. The testimony of Capt. Osborn, 138 East 23 Street, N.Y. City is especially important. He is acquainted with all the details relative to the arrival of skins, belongings etc. All the before mentioned articles namely, blue fox skins, narwhal horns, narwhal teeth and provisions were the common property of Dr. Cook and complainant. Cook had agreed with complainant that later on the amount received by the sale of the various articles would be divided between the two as compensation for the Expedition. Testimony of Cr. Cook and his letter, March 17-1908. Further, It must be taken into consideration that it is the right of an old custom to divide the spoils of such an expedition between the others of the same. In this case there were only Dr. Cook and the complainant who took part in the Expedition, so in accordance with this oldtime custom, they should share all share alike.

“When complainant declared all his belongings as Dr. Cook’s property and as such gave them over to defendant, it was with this idea to secure better protection as Dr. Cook is better known here and personally acquainted with defendant, while complainant is unknown, being for the first time in this region.

“The defendant is duty bound to make good to the complainant the value of the different articles. It has already been mentioned that complainant was seriously ill and unable to care for himself. He needed the care of a Dr. and the Whalers on board of which he had accepted to return were gone, therefore he was at the mercy of the defendant and compelled to accept his terms. As the Eric now remained the only ship on which he could return, all this the defendant knew and still refused to give complainant passage if he insisted upon taking his belongings with him.

“The complainant also learned that the statement made by defendant in which he declared the great need of the furs for his expedition to be untrue, as Complainant afterward learned that defendant was richly provided with skins and that same had already been fashioned into garments. Testimony Henry Jo[h]nson Arctic Club 139 E. 23rd Street New York City.

“As has already been testified to, the defendant had no need of the skins etc. for his expedition, but made presents with some of them, sent home by the Eric and turned the rest into money. The defendant doubtless made the presents to those in authority with a view of gaining their favor for himself, characteristic are the two letters of August 11 and 13th, which the defendant had ordered to be written to protect himself against future criticism. As soon as complainant brought his case before the public these letters were published in the New York Times, the paper favoring Peary.

“The date of the paper in which these letters were published is to be found in court. We have already mentioned and put under consideration of experienced people that the skins had a value of from 40 to 50 thousand mark, narwhal horns valued for 4200 to 4900 mark, walrus teeth valued 1000 mark, the total amount being from 45 to 55 thousand mark. The complainant has a right to claim one half of the amount revived by sale of said articles.

“In this case 20,000 mark are required to be paid by defendant to complainant.4

“All explanation and transaction in reference to the above mentioned case between defendant and complainant will be fought.

“The defendant is not in position to return the goods to complainant as he has either sold or made presents of same. On this account he has to be sworn in.

“In conclusion, it will be stated that the Complainant asked aid of the German Rotschafter (consolate) in Washington and was told to go to German authorities.

“Copy to be found in the Gerichtsschreiborei [Judicial Reporters], Berlin, June 8-1910

Lawyer,

Richard Thiel.”

1 At the time of this deposition, Frederick Cook had not been heard from since November 1909, and his whereabouts were unknown.

2 Actually the “narwhal teeth” were walrus tusks.

3 See these letters in previous posts in this series.

4 A German Mark at the time was equal to 20 cents, or 5 marks to the dollar. A dollar was worth approximately 25 times as much as it is today in buying power. So 20,000 M would be $4,000, with the buying power of today’s dollar of $100,000.

A typed copy of the deposition is among Peary’s papers at NARA II.

Uncategorized

Inside the Peary Expedition: Part 13: Aftermath: Spetember 1908; Franke reaches the United States

June 10, 2021

On August 18th Franke, still brooding over his dealings with Peary, watched the Roosevelt steam slowly north and vanish from sight among the ice of Smith Sound. Peary had forbidden him to take anything aboard the Erik besides his personal effects; he was not even allowed a pair of dogs he wanted to donate to the Catholic relief mission ship St. Bernard. The Roosevelt was hardly out of sight when Franke began to hear grumblings among the crew of the Erik about Peary’s unfair treatment of them, though while the commander had been present they had seemed totally subservient.

The day after the Roosevelt sailed, the Arctic, under the command of Captain Joseph Bernier, anchored in Etah’s harbor. Captain Bernier had hope to try for the North Pole himself in 1908, but the Canadian government had ordered him to visit the islands discovered by Sverdrup and claim Canadian sovereignty over them instead. One of Bernier assignments was to deliver 15 boxes of relief supplies sent by Marie Cook. Bernier also had 11 letters for Dr. Cook, which Franke took on the doctor’s behalf. He gave them to Harry Whitney for safekeeping, since he did not trust Peary’s men to deliver them. When Bernier tried to obtain a team of dogs to aid his explorations, Bos’n Murphy would not allow him to have a single animal, and after caching Cook’s supplies slightly south of Etah, the Arctic left Foulke Fjord bound for Jones Sound.

The meeting with Captain Bernier made Franke all the more depressed and resentful of Peary. Certainly, he thought, Peary must have known the Arctic was coming to Etah but had kept silent in order to extort from him Cook’s provisions and furs for his personal gain. He felt he now realized the extent of Peary’s unscrupulous nature and began to fear for Dr. Cook’s safety in case of his return, as Peary seemed capable of anything. But he had asked Panikpa to keep a watchful eye on things at Annoatok; in this, at least, Franke took comfort as the Erik left Etah on August 23rd . He did not know that at that moment Panikpa was bound for Cape Sheridan aboard the Roosevelt, along with many of the Eskimos who had accompanied Dr. Cook across Ellesmere Land, for further questioning.

Even the prospects of a tranquil voyage vanished when , on the evening of September 22nd the Erik collided with an iceberg that stove in her bow. After some frantic activity, it was determined that the severely damaged ship could still make port. Franke went below to discover that his trunk was also a casualty of the accident. Many of the photographic plat4es were destroyed, but he was able to save Dr. Cook’s diary.

When the Erik limped into Brigus the next day, he was hospitably greeted by Moses Bartlett, who had captained the Bradley. There he found that it was not September 23rd, as he thought, but September 30th. In the nightless Arctic summer he had lost count of seven days. The Erik managed to make it to St. John’s for repairs, and from there Franke took a boat to Sydney, where he caught the train for New York.

Once in the city he met with the secretary of the Arctic Club, B.S. Osbon. Osbon was a flamboyant character with many outspoken views. He knew all the inside gossip about Robert Peary and found him insufferably arrogant. When he heard Franke’s story of his dealings with Peary at Etah, he urged Franke to write a letter to Josephine Peary asking her to set things straight or he would report the affair publicly. Franke enclosed two copies of the letter, one in English and one in German, since Mrs. Peary spoke his native tongue:

[illegible N.Y. address]

Mrs. Robert E. Peary

Washington, D.C.

Madame:

While I am very sorry to do it, I cannot help

to write these lines to you. No doubt your hus-

band has mentioned me to you in his last letter

and told you that I met him at Etah, North Green-

land. When I first met your husband, sickness and

distressing fatiques had brought me near death, and

people said I could not live much longer.

I told your husband all concerning John Bradley’s

expedition and especially all about Dr. Cook in a

sincere frank and honest way, and was glad not only

to have met your husband but to have won a mutual

confidence. Unfortunately I found how much I was

mistaken on that in return trip on the “Erik” as to

my trust in your husband when I found out how unfair

a man could be, who called himself a gentleman. Let

me tell you my explanation. Among other things your

husband said, he could not allow that Dr. Cook’s be-

longings (about 200 fox skins and 7 narwhale horns)

to go with the Erik for he himself needed winter clo-

thing, etc., and he said he had never traded or

bought furs to be taken South. Your husband knew

that the furs and narwhale horns were Dr. Cook’s

property and how his action in obtaining the same

made him guilty. When I spoke to him the next

day about his action he told me literally:

“Do you think I would allow you to go home with the

furs on board the Eric? I never did it in my life

to send furs and something else home. I will shoulder

the responsibility with Dr. Cook myself.” I told all

I took and the whole thing was settled for me. My

health improved and I could walk around. I saw your

husband must have permitted to send furs home for I

saw boxes and bundles and took notice of some addresses.

found likewise that furs were dried in the salon of the

Eric; furs which belonged to Dr. Cook. When your hus-

band needed furs for winter clothing, why did he not

keep them on deck to be used for the benefit of his men

instead of sending them to you and other persons as pre-

sents: I have acted fair towards your husband. From the

instant I was told he had come here with an expedition.

I stopped buying and trading and left him everything

he needed. I am now busy with getting my report

ready and to be truthful I must mention this inci-

dent. The honor of your husband will very much

be doubted and I leave it to you to remedy this

occurrence in communicating with Mrs. Fred A. Cook.

All women are, as a rule, clever and wise and can

overcome difficulties easily, that are almost im-

possible for men. Please, help! I am writing the

truth to you and if necessary, I can swear too all

I have said above before court.

Sincerely yours

Rudolph Franke

When Jo Peary ignored Franke’s letters, Osbon made good on his promise of creating a “sensation” in the press by claiming Peary had used Franke’s desperate condition to extort from him supplies and valuable fur and ivory worth more than $5,000.

When it came time to write her letters to be delivered to her husband via the Arctic whalers, Jo warned him of the events that had ensued since he departed on his latest expedition:Jo letter

March 23, 1909

My Dearest,
The usual 6 copies of whaler letters are
to go on the 25th so here goes hoping & believing you
will not depend on them for news. Surely you
will come this Fall. You must. I could not
face another winter without you. I never
have wanted you as I have this last year.
The children have been fairly well & things have
gone well but I need you.
The Erik rammed an iceberg on a clear night
after leaving Cape Haven last Sept. & was badly
smashed but managed to reach St. John’s under
her own steam.
Cook & his friends may give you trouble.
That dog Franck told Osbon of the Arctic Club
that you stole all of Cook’s furs & ivory valued at
$5,000 & sent them as presents to Roosevelt,
your wife & others & drove Franck out of
the country at the point of your rifle.
Osbon published this & a lot of similar rot
& I simply had to allow Reick1 to publish
some of the correspondence between you &

Franck. The matter is to be taken up again

when you return according to Osbon.

Adm. Schley2 is pres. of the Arctic Club & is solic-
iting money for a relief ship for Cook
to be commanded by Dillon Wallace3.

1. William Reick, sub-editor of the New York Times.
2. Admiral Winfield Scott Schley’s connection with the Arctic came from his rescue of the survivors of Greely’s Lady Franklin Bay Expedition in 1884. He later was the hero of the Naval battle of Santiago during the Spanish American War.
3. Dillon Wallace was a lawyer and best selling author, who mounted three expeditions to Labrador. He was a personal friend of Dr. Cook’s and a fellow member of the Arctic Club.

A typed copy of Franke’s letter and Jo’s letter is at NARA II.

Uncategorized

Inside the Peary Expedition: Part 12: August 17; Peary prepares to sail north

May 19, 2021

After a walrus hunt to provide the Inuit with meat lost by his taking some of the best hunters north with him, Peary prepared to sail. He put the Bos’n, John Murphy in charge of Cook’s box house at Annoatok, to live there and guard the supplies Cook had brought against pilfering by the natives. To keep him company and keep the log, as Murphy was perfectly illiterate, he assigned Billy Pritchard, the Roosevelt’s cabin boy to stay with him. Peary wrote out a set of detailed instructions for Pritchard to read to Murphy to remind him of how he was to spend his time.

The instructions he left are long and tedious, so no transcription is provided here. Ross Marvin’s handwritten copy of the instructions, signed by Peary, is generally legible, so the interested reader can read them from the original, dated at Etah, August 17, 1908, which is reproduced below and is now at NARA II.August 17 instructions 1

Instructions 2Instructions 3Instructions 4Instructions 5Instructions 6

Although he declared in the opening paragraph that he was leaving the men “in charge of the station here for the relief of Dr. Cook,” Peary wrote to his wife what his true intentions actually were:

August 17 Peary to Peary

I have Sammy1 on board to
prevent Cook from taking him back.

The Cook circumstances have given
me a good deal of extra work &
trouble; but have worked out satis-
factorily.

I have landed supplies here, &
leave two men ostensibly in behalf
of Cook. As a matter of fact I
have established here the sub-base
which last time I established at Vic-
toria Head, as a precaution against
in event of loss of the R– either
going up this fall or coming down
next Summer.

In some respects this is an advan-
tage as on leaving here there is nothing to delay me or keep me from taking either side of the Channel going up.

The conditions give me entire control of the situation.

Most of Peary’s dictated instructions are concerned with bartering away Cook’s supplies for fox and other valuable pelts.

Peary had planned to head north that day, but rain, snow and fog prevented him sailing. But he was able to do so on August 18th. As with everything else, Dr. Goodsell recorded the departure in his diary:

“Whitney, Norton, Learned and Craft2 came aboard to bid us good bye, and wish us success. The Erik will remain at Etah for a couple of days, completing the unloading of the coal to be left at Etah for the Roosevelt.
The weather was bad during the morning, but in the afternoon the sun came out and the fog disappeared. It was a pleasant afternoon, and the kind of weather we might desire for a start.
At last the farewell given, we are away for Cape Sheridan and our winter quarters.”

And so Peary sailed and would not be heard from by the world at large at all until his message was flashed to the world on September 6, 1909, from Battle Harbour, Labrador: “Stars and Stripes nailed to the North Pole.”

As for Rudolph Franke, he watched as what only could be the skins he and Cook had collected over the winter were loaded aboard the Erik. Franke had signed a receipt given to him by Ross Marvin acknowledging the $50 in gold given him for his expenses in getting back to New York. Later Herbert L. Bridgman, Secretary of the Peary Arctic Club, billed Mrs. Cook for the cost of Franke’s “relief.” This receipt is now in the Peary papers at NARA II.August 17 Franke receipt

1. “Sammy” was Peary’s first illegitimate son, whose Inuit name was Anaukaq. Apparently, Peary feared Cook might attempt to take him back to the United States to embarrass him. To prevent this, Peary took him north on the Roosevelt.

2. These were all paying “guests” aboard the Roosevelt. Each had paid Peary $500 ($12,500 in today’s buying power) for the privilege of accompanying him to Greenland. All returned with the Erik except for Harry Whitney, who spent the winter at Dr. Cook’s box house at Annoatok and witnessed his return there in April of 1909.

Uncategorized